
Roots
Consider, for a moment, the whisper of ancestral voices carried on a gentle breeze, a song sung through generations about the earth’s bounty. For those whose lineage traces to the vast, vibrant expanse of Africa, this song often carries the deep, resonant notes of shea. For textured hair, especially, this golden butter, pressed from the nut of the sacred shea tree, represents more than a mere ingredient; it embodies a heritage, a living connection to practices centuries old.
It is an enduring testament to the ingenuity and wisdom of those who first understood its remarkable capacities. How does this earthly gift, born of the savanna, become so profoundly intertwined with the very fiber of textured hair’s story?
The story of shea butter for textured hair begins in the biological symphony of the human scalp and strand itself. Textured hair, with its unique helical twists and turns, often presents a different challenge regarding moisture retention when compared to straighter hair types. The natural sebum, the scalp’s own moisturizing balm, struggles to traverse the intricate curves of coily and curly strands, leaving the hair often prone to dryness and breakage.
This inherent characteristic of textured hair, often seen as a vulnerability in modern contexts, was understood and honored by ancestral communities. They sought solutions within their immediate environment, and in the heart of West and Central Africa, the shea tree, Vitellaria Paradoxa, offered a profound answer.

Understanding Textured Hair Anatomy and Physiology
The architecture of textured hair is distinct. Each strand is not a simple, smooth column, but rather a complex helix, ranging from broad waves to tightly wound coils. This structural complexity influences how moisture behaves upon the hair shaft. Imagine water trying to flow down a winding river with many bends and turns; it moves differently than a straight, swift current.
Similarly, natural oils struggle to evenly coat a highly coiled strand from root to tip. This inherent dryness makes textured hair particularly susceptible to environmental stressors, requiring external emollients to maintain its suppleness and strength. Ancestral wisdom recognized this need for deep conditioning and protection, leading to the early and consistent application of plant-derived butters like shea.
Shea butter’s historical significance for textured hair care is deeply rooted in its unparalleled ability to address the unique moisture needs of coily and curly strands, a wisdom passed down through generations.
The chemical composition of shea butter speaks to its efficacy. It is a treasure trove of fatty acids, including oleic, stearic, linoleic, and palmitic acids. These components work in concert to seal moisture into the hair cuticle, acting as a protective shield.
Moreover, the presence of Vitamins A and E, along with other non-saponifiable lipids, grants shea butter notable anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties. Such attributes were perhaps not understood through a scientific lens by early users, but their empirical observations of its soothing and fortifying effects were undeniably accurate.

Lexicon of Textured Hair and Traditional Connections
Within African societies, the understanding of hair, its textures, and its care was woven into the fabric of daily life and communal identity. Hair was not just hair; it was a map, a symbol, a declaration. Traditional terms, though varying by region and language, often reflected the reverence for hair and the specific care it demanded.
While direct ancestral terms for ‘shea butter’ in relation to ‘textured hair type X’ are complex and region-specific, the widespread application of shea for its emollient properties is a constant. It was a universal balm for the hair, softening, protecting, and preparing it for the intricate styles that marked identity.
- Karité ❉ The common name for shea in many West African regions, literally meaning “tree of life” in some local dialects, underscoring its broad significance.
- Ori ❉ A Yoruba term, which can refer to shea butter itself, but also carries deeper spiritual connotations of one’s inner head or destiny, often associated with head anointing rituals that included shea.
- Kpakpo Shito ❉ A traditional Ghanaian term for a variety of shea butter uses, highlighting its versatility in daily life, including personal care.
Understanding these terms and their cultural contexts offers a glimpse into how deeply shea butter was integrated into the holistic perception of well-being and beauty across the continent. Its application was not merely cosmetic; it was a ritual of self-preservation and cultural affirmation.

How Does Shea’s Biology Align with Ancient Hair Care?
The unique physiology of textured hair, particularly its predisposition to dryness due to the coiling nature that hinders sebum distribution along the hair shaft, made natural emollients indispensable in ancestral care routines. Shea butter, with its rich fatty acid profile, provided a potent solution to this inherent challenge. It served as a protective sealant, reducing moisture loss and adding a necessary layer of lubrication to the hair strands. This biological compatibility between shea’s properties and textured hair’s needs cemented its place in centuries of hair care practices.
| Ancestral Observation of Shea's Impact Softens hair, makes it pliable for styling. |
| Modern Scientific Understanding Fatty acids (oleic, stearic) coat the hair shaft, reducing friction and increasing pliability. |
| Ancestral Observation of Shea's Impact Reduces breakage, helps hair grow long. |
| Modern Scientific Understanding Minimizes moisture loss, fortifies the hair's lipid barrier, leading to less breakage and better length retention. |
| Ancestral Observation of Shea's Impact Soothes itchy or dry scalp. |
| Modern Scientific Understanding Anti-inflammatory properties, like amyrin, calm scalp irritation and provide hydration. |
| Ancestral Observation of Shea's Impact Protects hair from sun and wind. |
| Modern Scientific Understanding Presence of cinnamic acid esters offers natural UV protection, shielding hair from environmental aggressors. |
| Ancestral Observation of Shea's Impact The enduring utility of shea butter for textured hair care stands as a testament to traditional wisdom validated by contemporary scientific inquiry. |
Indeed, the archaeological record itself offers a compelling testament to shea’s enduring presence. Anthropological research at sites like Kirikongo in Burkina Faso indicates the processing and use of shea nuts as far back as 100 CE, predating earlier assumptions by a thousand years. This archaeological evidence underscores the deep historical reliance on shea within these communities, not just for sustenance but also for its profound cosmetic applications, a tradition passed through countless generations.

Ritual
The golden, creamy texture of shea butter, born from the patient hands of African women, has for centuries served as a cornerstone of hair care rituals. These practices extend beyond simple application; they are acts steeped in cultural meaning, community connection, and a deep respect for the hair as a sacred part of identity. The historical use of shea butter is inseparable from the very styling techniques that have defined textured hair heritage, from protective styles to daily adornment. It served as the pliable medium, the protective shield, and the nourishing foundation for crowns that spoke volumes without uttering a single word.

Ancestral Protective Styling Roots
Protective styling, a widely recognized method for safeguarding textured hair from environmental damage and reducing manipulation, holds ancient roots. Styles such as braids, twists, and cornrows were not simply aesthetic choices in various African societies; they were intricate symbols of identity, status, age, marital standing, and even spiritual connection. Before the tragic period of transatlantic enslavement, hair styling was a profound means of communication and classification. Shea butter was an indispensable aid in crafting and preserving these elaborate styles.
Its rich, emollient nature provided the necessary slip for braiding and twisting, minimizing breakage while also lending a healthy sheen to the hair. It allowed for the creation of styles that could endure for weeks or even months, protecting the hair and scalp from harsh climates and daily wear.
The historical journey of shea butter through ancestral hair care rituals mirrors the resilience and creativity embedded within textured hair traditions across African communities.
Consider the detailed processes of preparing hair for protective styles. Often, this involved communal gatherings, where women shared knowledge, stories, and the soothing application of shea butter. This ritualistic aspect solidified social bonds and transmitted ancestral wisdom from one generation to the next. The butter would condition the hair, making it supple and less prone to tangling during the meticulous braiding process.
This practice contrasts sharply with the forced hair shaving imposed during enslavement, a brutal act aimed at stripping away identity and cultural connection. The continued use of shea butter, even in the face of such dehumanization, became a quiet act of resistance, a way to maintain a semblance of heritage.

Influence on Styling and Definition
Shea butter’s role extends beyond the creation of protective styles. It has been a constant companion in the artistry of natural styling and definition. The quest for well-defined curls and coils, or for a smooth, lustrous finish on stretched hair, was met through various applications of shea.
It was used as a daily moisturizer, rubbed into the scalp and along the hair strands to soften, add gloss, and prevent the brittle dryness that often characterizes textured hair. Its properties helped clumps of curls to form and hold their shape, allowing for dynamic, sculptural styles.
The traditional processing of shea butter itself speaks to its heritage. Rural women in West Africa traditionally process shea nuts through a laborious, multi-step process involving harvesting, drying, cracking, roasting, grinding, kneading, and boiling. This painstaking effort underscores the immense value placed on this ingredient, not merely as a commodity, but as a vital component of cultural life and personal care.
The warmth generated during the kneading process, often performed by hand, would help to emulsify the butter, making it more penetrative and easier to apply to the hair. This traditional method, which still accounts for a significant portion of raw shea butter production, reinforces the ancestral connection to the ingredient.

Shea Butter in Hair Tools and Techniques
The tools and techniques of textured hair care, too, have a rich, complex history, often intertwined with shea butter’s application. While modern combs and brushes abound, traditional implements like wide-toothed combs, wooden picks, or even fingers were historically used in conjunction with shea. The butter would lubricate the hair, facilitating gentle detangling and minimizing breakage, a constant concern for highly coily strands.
Shea butter’s protective qualities also extended to how hair withstood various environmental conditions. In arid climates, the butter provided a barrier against harsh sun and wind, preventing moisture loss and scalp irritation. It was a shield, allowing hair to remain pliable and strong despite external challenges. This protective capability meant hair could retain length and vibrancy, contributing to the symbolism of strength and vitality often associated with long, well-kept hair in many African cultures.
It is important to acknowledge that not all historical hair care practices involved heat, but where heat was used, often for stretching or styling, shea butter played a part. While the concept of “thermal reconditioning” is a modern one, traditional methods of hair stretching using heat from hot coals or simple metal tools would have required a protective agent. Shea butter, with its relatively high melting point and ability to coat the hair, would have helped mitigate damage and impart a sheen, a practice that echoes the modern use of heat protectants. The transition from purely traditional, low-manipulation styles to those influenced by external beauty standards often required adapting ancestral ingredients to new methods, with shea butter remaining a versatile choice.

Relay
The enduring legacy of shea butter in textured hair care represents a profound relay of ancestral wisdom, a continuous stream of knowledge passed from generation to generation. It informs our contemporary understanding of holistic hair health, offering a bridge between the deeply rooted practices of the past and the sophisticated scientific insights of the present. This golden balm, truly “women’s gold” in many African communities, has shaped regimens, resolved hair challenges, and continually asserted itself as a cornerstone of wellbeing for textured strands.

Holistic Care Guided by Ancestral Wisdom
Building personalized textured hair regimens today finds its inspiration in the holistic approaches of African ancestors. For these communities, hair care was never isolated; it was an integral part of overall health, spirituality, and social connection. The application of shea butter, often accompanied by massage and communal gathering, was a ritual for the body and the soul. This profound perspective informs modern calls for routines that prioritize gentle manipulation, consistent moisture, and nutrient-rich ingredients.
The tradition of using natural oils and butters, particularly shea, for hydration and scalp health has been consistently documented across various African cultures. For instance, in a study focusing on traditional plant cosmetics used by women in Northern Ghana, Shea Butter (Vitellaria Paradoxa) was Overwhelmingly Identified as the Most Used Plant for Enhancing Hair Growth and Smoothening Hair by 13.3% of Respondents for Hair Growth and 33.4% for Skin Smoothening among 228 Women Using Plants for Cosmetic Purposes Out of 383 Surveyed Respondents, underscoring its significant historical and ongoing relevance (Adomako et al. 2024, p.
5). This statistical finding provides tangible evidence of shea butter’s longstanding prominence in ancestral hair care practices and its perceived efficacy for healthy hair, a direct correlation to textured hair heritage.

Nighttime Sanctuary and Bonnet Wisdom
The practice of protecting textured hair during sleep, often with bonnets or head wraps, is not a modern invention; it too has ancestral roots. In many African cultures, head coverings held immense social, spiritual, and protective significance. These coverings safeguarded intricate hairstyles from dust and damage, preserved moisture, and symbolized modesty or status. Shea butter would often be applied as part of an evening ritual, sealing moisture into the hair before it was carefully wrapped or braided for the night.
This practice was, and remains, crucial for preventing friction-induced breakage and maintaining hair integrity over extended periods, especially for those with tightly coiled hair prone to dryness. The modern satin bonnet, therefore, is a direct descendant of a long-standing heritage of nighttime hair preservation, a testament to the enduring wisdom of such simple yet effective strategies.
The quiet nightly ritual of protecting textured hair, often with shea-infused preparations, echoes ancient wisdom on preserving hair health and honoring its sanctity.

Ingredient Insights for Textured Hair Needs
Shea butter’s rich composition, with its beneficial fatty acids and vitamins, speaks directly to the needs of textured hair. Its emollient properties provide deep conditioning, while its ability to form a protective barrier on the hair shaft guards against moisture loss and environmental damage. This makes it particularly valuable for low-porosity hair, where it helps to seal in hydration, and for high-porosity hair, where it aids in preventing rapid moisture escape.
Consider these historically valued attributes of shea butter for hair:
- Moisture Sealant ❉ Its fatty acids (oleic, stearic, linoleic) effectively coat the hair, reducing water evaporation, which is crucial for textured hair prone to dryness.
- Scalp Soother ❉ The anti-inflammatory compounds, such as amyrin, calm irritated scalps, addressing conditions that could impede healthy hair growth.
- Elasticity Enhancer ❉ Regular application helps improve hair’s elasticity, making it more resilient and less susceptible to breakage during manipulation.
Beyond shea, a rich tapestry of other ancestral ingredients has historically supported textured hair health:
- Castor Oil ❉ Known for its viscosity and purported ability to thicken hair and promote growth, used across various African and diasporic communities.
- Aloe Vera ❉ Valued for its soothing and hydrating properties, often applied to the scalp to calm irritation.
- Chebe Powder ❉ An herbal mixture from Chad, traditionally used by Basara women for length retention, applied as a paste with oils and butters to the hair.
The interplay of these ingredients with shea butter demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of botanical properties, cultivated through generations of observation and practice.

Problem Solving with Ancestral Solutions
From addressing dryness and breakage to managing scalp conditions, shea butter has been a primary remedy in the compendium of textured hair problem-solving. Its deep moisturizing capacity directly counters the inherent dryness of coily hair, a common concern across centuries. For ancestral communities, hair breakage meant a reduction in the visual length and density of their crowns, which often held symbolic meaning. Shea butter’s ability to reduce breakage by keeping hair supple and protected was therefore not just a matter of aesthetics; it was a preservation of identity and cultural expression.
| Hair Challenge Dryness and Brittleness |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Daily application as a leave-in moisturizer to seal in moisture. |
| Contemporary Relevance Forms the base of many modern moisturizing creams and butters for curly hair. |
| Hair Challenge Scalp Irritation and Flakiness |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Massaging butter into the scalp to soothe and nourish. |
| Contemporary Relevance Anti-inflammatory properties recognized in contemporary scalp treatments. |
| Hair Challenge Breakage and Loss of Length |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Using it to lubricate hair for protective styles like braiding, reducing friction. |
| Contemporary Relevance Acts as a sealant and conditioning agent in pre-poo and styling routines to minimize manipulation damage. |
| Hair Challenge Lack of Shine and Luster |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Applied to hair for natural sheen and a healthy look. |
| Contemporary Relevance Adds natural gloss and softness to finished styles without synthetic additives. |
| Hair Challenge The enduring utility of shea butter for addressing common textured hair issues highlights its timeless effectiveness, a testament to ancestral ingenuity. |
The historical evidence points to shea butter’s consistent use as a natural remedy for maintaining healthy hair and scalp in various challenging environments. Its versatility allowed it to be incorporated into diverse practices, making it an indispensable element of textured hair care, particularly for Black and mixed-race communities for whom hair has always been a powerful symbol of identity and resilience.

Relay
The continuous passage of knowledge surrounding shea butter’s profound benefits for textured hair represents a vibrant current, a relay of wisdom that bridges ancestral practices with our contemporary understanding. This golden butter, often called “women’s gold” in its African homelands, is more than an ingredient; it is a vital part of a living heritage, a tangible link to the profound care and ingenuity of those who came before us. It has consistently shaped daily regimens, offered solutions to perennial hair challenges, and steadily affirmed its standing as a cornerstone of holistic wellbeing for textured strands across generations.

Holistic Care Guided by Ancestral Wisdom
The creation of personalized textured hair regimens today draws deeply from the holistic approaches prevalent in African ancestral communities. For these societies, hair care was never a separate endeavor; it was intricately woven into the broader fabric of spiritual connection, communal life, and overall health. The act of applying shea butter, frequently accompanied by gentle massage and often shared during gatherings, was a ritual for both the physical body and the inner spirit. This profound perspective continues to inform modern calls for routines that prioritize gentle handling, consistent moisture, and the selection of nutrient-rich ingredients.
The tradition of relying on natural oils and butters, especially shea, for deep hydration and scalp vitality has been consistently documented across diverse African cultures. An ethnobotanical study focusing on traditional plant cosmetics used by women in Northern Ghana revealed shea butter (Vitellaria paradoxa) as the most frequently employed plant. Specifically, 13.3% of Surveyed Women Used It for Promoting Hair Growth, While 33.4% Applied It for Skin Smoothening among the 228 Respondents Who Reported Using Plants for Cosmetic Purposes Out of a Total of 383 Participants (Adomako et al. 2024, p.
5). This quantifiable data provides clear evidence of shea butter’s historical and continuing prominence in ancestral hair care practices, directly connecting its perceived efficacy to the textured hair heritage.

Nighttime Sanctuary and Bonnet Wisdom
The consistent practice of safeguarding textured hair during sleep, often through the use of bonnets or protective head wraps, is not a recent innovation. This tradition, too, has deep ancestral roots. In numerous African cultures, head coverings carried immense symbolic, protective, and social weight. These coverings served to shield intricate hairstyles from dust and damage, to preserve the hair’s vital moisture, and to signify aspects of modesty or social standing.
Shea butter would frequently be a part of an evening ritual, carefully applied to seal hydration into the hair before it was meticulously wrapped or braided for the night. This practice was, and continues to be, fundamental for preventing breakage caused by friction and for maintaining the integrity of the hair over extended periods, particularly for those with tightly coiled hair which is inherently prone to dryness. Thus, the contemporary satin bonnet stands as a direct descendant of a long-established heritage of nighttime hair preservation, a quiet testimony to the enduring wisdom of these deceptively simple yet remarkably effective strategies.
The quiet nightly ritual of protecting textured hair, often with shea-infused preparations, echoes ancient wisdom on preserving hair health and honoring its sanctity.

Ingredient Insights for Textured Hair Needs
The rich biochemical composition of shea butter, with its beneficial fatty acids and vital vitamins, speaks directly to the inherent needs of textured hair. Its emollient qualities deliver deep conditioning, while its capacity to form a protective film upon the hair shaft acts as a guard against moisture loss and environmental stressors. This makes shea butter especially valuable for both low-porosity hair, where it aids in sealing in moisture, and for high-porosity hair, where it helps in preventing the rapid escape of hydration.
Consider these long-valued attributes of shea butter for hair:
- Moisture Retention ❉ Its fatty acids (oleic, stearic, linoleic) effectively coat the hair, significantly reducing water evaporation, which is paramount for textured hair’s common battle with dryness.
- Scalp Comfort ❉ The anti-inflammatory compounds, such as amyrin, provide soothing relief to irritated scalps, addressing conditions that could hinder healthy hair growth.
- Suppleness Contributor ❉ Regular application aids in improving hair’s suppleness, rendering it more resilient and less susceptible to snapping during styling or daily movement.
Beyond shea, a vibrant array of other ancestral ingredients has historically supported textured hair vitality:
- Castor Oil ❉ Recognized for its density and perceived ability to enhance hair thickness and encourage growth, widely used across various African and diasporic communities.
- Aloe Vera ❉ Highly regarded for its calming and hydrating properties, frequently applied directly to the scalp to alleviate irritation.
- Chebe Powder ❉ A unique herbal blend originating from Chad, traditionally used by Basara women for exceptional length retention, applied as a paste with oils and butters to the hair.
The interplay of these ingredients with shea butter demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of botanical properties, carefully cultivated through countless generations of empirical observation and dedicated practice.

Problem Solving with Ancestral Solutions
From addressing persistent dryness and breakage to managing various scalp conditions, shea butter has been a primary remedy in the extensive compendium of textured hair problem-solving. Its remarkable deep moisturizing capacity directly counteracts the inherent dryness of coily hair, a universal concern across centuries. For ancestral communities, hair breakage often signified a reduction in the visible length and density of their crowns, which frequently carried significant symbolic meaning. Shea butter’s ability to reduce breakage by keeping hair pliable and well-protected was therefore not simply a matter of external aesthetics; it represented a preservation of identity and cultural expression.
| Hair Challenge Persistent Dryness and Brittleness |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Regular application as a leave-in moisturizer to lock in hydration. |
| Contemporary Utility Forms a foundational component of many modern moisturizing creams and butters for curly hair. |
| Hair Challenge Scalp Discomfort and Flakiness |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Massaging butter into the scalp to soothe and nourish. |
| Contemporary Utility Anti-inflammatory properties are acknowledged in contemporary scalp treatments designed for sensitive skin. |
| Hair Challenge Hair Fractures and Length Reduction |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Using it to lubricate hair for protective styles like braiding, thereby reducing friction. |
| Contemporary Utility Acts as a sealing and conditioning agent in pre-shampoo and styling routines to minimize mechanical damage. |
| Hair Challenge Dullness and Absence of Shine |
| Traditional Shea Butter Solution Applied to hair for natural gloss and a healthy, vibrant appearance. |
| Contemporary Utility Imparts natural luminosity and softness to finished styles without requiring synthetic additives. |
| Hair Challenge The enduring utility of shea butter for addressing common textured hair issues highlights its timeless effectiveness, a profound testament to ancestral ingenuity. |
The historical record consistently shows shea butter’s steadfast use as a natural remedy for maintaining healthy hair and scalp, even in particularly challenging environmental conditions. Its versatility allowed for its seamless incorporation into diverse practices, positioning it as an indispensable element of textured hair care, particularly for Black and mixed-race communities for whom hair has always embodied a powerful symbol of identity, resilience, and ancestral connection.

Reflection
To gaze upon a strand of textured hair is to witness a universe of heritage, a testament to journeys taken, stories held, and resilience expressed. At the heart of this universe, often unseen yet profoundly felt, is the enduring legacy of shea butter. Its journey from the sun-drenched savannas of Africa, through the skilled hands of generations of women, to its celebrated place in contemporary hair care, is a powerful reaffirmation of ancestral wisdom. It is a reminder that the most profound solutions often arise from a deep, respectful relationship with the earth and its offerings.
Shea butter is more than a product; it is a memory, a comfort, a cultural touchstone. For textured hair, it has been a constant source of nourishment, protection, and beauty, enabling countless individuals to honor their natural crowns. As we move forward, continuing to rediscover and celebrate the unique aspects of textured hair, the story of shea butter will remain a guiding light.
It symbolizes a living library of practices and insights, ensuring that the soul of each strand, with its intricate history and boundless future, is not merely cared for, but revered. This rich heritage ensures shea butter’s influence will continue to ripple through the world of textured hair care, forever connecting us to the ancient rhythms of the land and the wisdom of our forebears.
References
- Adomako, M. Danso, L. Abass, M. B. & Oduro, I. N. (2024). Ethnobotany of traditional plant cosmetics utilized by women; A study in Northern Ghana. ResearchGate .
- Byrd, A. D. & Tharps, L. D. (2001). Hair Story ❉ Untangling the Roots of Black Hair in America. St. Martin’s Press.
- Gallagher, D. McIntosh, S. K. & D’Andrea, A. C. (2016). The Archaeology of Shea Butter (Vitellaria paradoxa) in Burkina Faso, West Africa. Journal of Ethnobiology, 36(1), 243-261.
- Lamien, N. Ouattara, D. & Sawadogo, M. (1996). Vitellaria paradoxa ❉ A review of its ethnomedicine and ethnobotany. Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 52(1), 3-10.
- Maranz, S. & Wiesman, Z. (2003). Shea Butter ❉ A Global Commodity ❉ Chemical, Biological, Nutritional, Agricultural and Socioeconomic Characteristics. CRC Press.
- Okereke, E. (2012). The History of Black Hair ❉ Textures, Styles, and Care. African World Press.
- Popenoe, R. (2004). Feeding Desire ❉ Fatness, Beauty, and Power Among the Azawagh Arabs of Niger. Routledge.
- Sieber, R. & Herreman, D. (2000). Hair in African Art and Culture. African American Museum of Art.
- Thompson, C. (2009). Hair Story ❉ Untangling the Roots of Black Hair in America. Picador.
- Zimmerman, M. A. (2000). Empowerment Theory ❉ Psychological, Organizational and Community Levels of Analysis. Handbook of Community Psychology, 1(1), 43-63.