Can ancestral oiling truly protect textured hair today?

Roots

In the quiet spaces of our collective memory, where the whispers of generations past still linger, a profound question arises ❉ Can ancestral oiling truly protect textured hair today? This query is not a mere technicality about hair care; it is an invitation to walk through the rich, verdant fields of textured hair heritage , to listen to the echoes of ancient practices, and to consider how these time-honored rituals hold meaning and efficacy in our contemporary world. For those whose strands coil and spring with the resilience of a history both vibrant and complex, this inquiry touches upon identity, tradition, and the very act of self-preservation. We stand at a unique intersection, poised to observe how the wisdom of our forebears, particularly in the use of oils, continues to offer a shield against the challenges of modern living, all while honoring the intrinsic beauty of our hair’s lineage.

Hair Anatomy and Its Ancestral Connection

To truly comprehend the protective capacity of ancestral oiling, one must first grasp the biological architecture of textured hair. Unlike straight or wavy hair, strands with a tighter curl pattern possess an elliptical cross-section, a characteristic that causes the cuticle layers—the outermost protective scales—to lift more readily. This unique structure, a biological marvel, means that natural sebum, the scalp’s inherent conditioning oil, struggles to travel down the length of the hair shaft, leaving the mid-lengths and ends susceptible to dryness. This inherent dryness, often perceived as a vulnerability, is precisely what ancient practices sought to address through external applications.

From the earliest communal gatherings, where hair care was a shared ritual, our ancestors recognized this need for external nourishment. The very act of applying oils became a form of communal wisdom , a shared understanding of how to sustain the vitality of hair in diverse climates and environments.

Historically, hair was not merely an aesthetic adornment; it served as a powerful communicator of one’s social status , ethnic identity , marital standing, and even spiritual beliefs in pre-colonial Africa. The intricate styling processes, which often involved washing, combing, oiling, and braiding, were not quick tasks but rather extended periods of bonding among family and friends. This ritualistic application of oils, therefore, was deeply embedded within a broader cultural framework that prioritized hair health as a sign of vitality and well-being. The act of oiling was a deliberate, mindful step in preserving the hair’s integrity, ensuring its readiness for elaborate styles that spoke volumes without a single uttered word.

Hair Classification and Its Historical Roots

The contemporary systems used to classify textured hair, such as the Andre Walker Hair Typing System, categorize hair into types (1-4) with subcategories (A-C) based on curl pattern and density. While widely adopted today, it is important to acknowledge the historical undercurrents of hair classification. Early 20th-century systems, unfortunately, were often rooted in racial categorization, aiming to determine proximity to whiteness based on hair texture.

Eugen Fischer, a German scientist in 1908, developed a “hair gauge” to classify Namibians’ hair texture in support of racist ideologies. This troubling past underscores the need for a heritage-conscious approach to hair science, one that celebrates the diversity of textured hair rather than ranking it.

The modern hair typing system, while imperfect, can offer a practical guideline for understanding how different textures respond to products, including oils. For instance, tightly coiled hair, often categorized as Type 4, tends to be more porous and less able to retain moisture due to its cuticle structure. This characteristic makes the application of oils particularly relevant for sealing in hydration. Conversely, looser curl patterns might require lighter oils to avoid weighing them down.

The ancestral knowledge, passed down through generations, often intuitively understood these differences, selecting specific plant-derived oils and butters that were best suited for their particular hair textures and environmental conditions. This understanding was not codified in scientific papers but lived within the oral traditions and daily practices of communities.

Ancestral oiling practices, rooted in the biological nuances of textured hair, provided a vital protective layer, addressing its inherent dryness and supporting its health long before modern science articulated porosity or cuticle structure.

Traditional Lexicon and Hair’s Deep Past

The language surrounding textured hair care is as rich and varied as the hair itself, carrying within it the echoes of countless generations. Terms like “nappy,” once used as a derogatory descriptor, have been reappropriated by people of African descent, transformed into symbols of pride and self-acceptance. This linguistic reclamation mirrors the broader movement to celebrate natural hair heritage . Within traditional contexts, specific names for oils, tools, and practices held deep meaning, often tied to local flora and communal rituals.

Consider the Chebe tradition of the Basara Tribe in Chad, where a specific herb-infused oil and animal fat mixture is applied weekly for length retention. This practice is not merely about product application; it is an intricate ritual with significant cultural meaning. Similarly, women of Ethiopian and Somali descent historically used a homemade “hair butter” of whipped animal milk and water for hair maintenance, yielding excellent results. These are not just recipes; they are linguistic markers of a profound ancestral knowledge system , where each ingredient and action carries a history of efficacy and cultural relevance.

Understanding these terms, and the practices they represent, helps us to reconnect with the deeper significance of oiling beyond superficial beauty. It allows us to appreciate the ingenuity of our forebears who, without microscopes or chemical analyses, discerned the protective qualities of natural substances and applied them with intention and reverence.

The history of African hair, stretching from pre-colonial Africa to the present day, serves as a powerful testament to identity, resistance, and self-expression. Hair has been a symbol of communication, distinguishing status, geographic origin, and even spiritual power. The intricate hair styling processes, involving oiling and adornment, were social opportunities for bonding. This legacy, intertwined with the very biology of textured hair, forms the essential groundwork for understanding how ancestral oiling continues to shield and strengthen our strands today.

Ritual

As we move from the fundamental understanding of textured hair’s unique composition, a new layer of inquiry unfolds ❉ How has ancestral oiling shaped the very ritual of care, influencing styling techniques and transformations across generations? Perhaps you have felt the gentle pull of tradition, the quiet knowing that certain gestures and ingredients hold a power beyond the tangible. This section invites us into the sacred space of shared, ancestral and contemporary practical knowledge , where the rhythmic application of oils transforms into a dance between past and present, offering guidance rooted in deep respect for tradition. It is here, within the practices themselves, that the enduring efficacy of ancestral oiling reveals itself, not as a static relic, but as a living, breathing component of our textured hair heritage .

Protective Styling and Its Ancestral Roots

The concept of protective styling, so vital to the health of textured hair today, finds its origins in ancestral practices that predated modern terminology. For centuries, African communities employed various braiding, twisting, and wrapping techniques not only for aesthetic and social expression but also to shield hair from environmental stressors and minimize manipulation. Oils and butters were integral to these styles, providing lubrication, sealing in moisture, and reducing friction that could lead to breakage. This thoughtful pairing of protective styles with oil application was a cornerstone of traditional hair maintenance .

During the transatlantic slave trade, the deliberate shaving of enslaved Africans’ heads was an act designed to dehumanize and strip them of their identity. Yet, even under such brutal conditions, the resilience of hair heritage persisted. Enslaved individuals, when afforded a moment of reprieve, would use whatever available greases or oils—such as butter or goose grease—to maintain their hair in plaits, braids, and cornrows.

These styles were not just practical for hygiene; they became acts of silent protest, a means of preserving a connection to their homeland and asserting their worth. This historical context underscores the deep protective intent behind ancestral oiling within protective styles, a practice born of necessity and sustained by an unbreakable spirit.

• Cornrows ❉ Known in some regions as “canerows,” these tightly braided rows against the scalp were both practical and deeply symbolic, sometimes encoding messages for escape during slavery.
• Bantu Knots ❉ A traditional style of the Zulu Tribe of South Africa, these coiled knots provided a compact, protective way to manage hair.
• Locs ❉ Ceremonial styles of the Maasai tribe in Kenya and Tanzania, reflecting a long history of spiritual and cultural significance.

Natural Styling and Definition Techniques

The pursuit of defined curls and coils, a contemporary aspiration for many with textured hair, echoes ancestral methods that focused on enhancing the natural form. While modern products promise definition, traditional approaches relied on the inherent properties of oils and butters to provide slip, sheen, and hold. The application of oils often accompanied detangling rituals, allowing combs made from natural materials to glide through strands with less resistance. This gentle manipulation, combined with the conditioning properties of oils, helped to maintain the integrity of the curl pattern.

The practice of hair oiling in West African traditions, for example, aimed to keep hair moisturized in hot, dry climates, often alongside protective styles. The Basara Tribe’s use of Chebe, an herb-infused oil mixture, is specifically noted for extreme length retention when applied to braided hair. This suggests a sophisticated understanding of how oils contribute to the hair’s elasticity and resilience, preventing the microscopic breaks that lead to apparent length stagnation.

The ancestral approach to natural styling was not about altering the hair’s inherent structure but rather about supporting its natural inclinations, allowing its inherent beauty to shine through. It was a practice of working with, rather than against, the hair’s given form.

The enduring practice of ancestral oiling, woven into the fabric of protective styles and natural curl enhancement, reveals a deep, inherited wisdom about sustaining textured hair against historical challenges and environmental demands.

The Complete Textured Hair Toolkit

The tools of ancestral hair care were as elemental and ingenious as the ingredients themselves. Before the advent of modern brushes and chemical relaxers, communities crafted implements from natural resources, each designed to work harmoniously with textured hair and the oils applied to it. These tools were not just functional objects; they were extensions of a communal hand, passed down through generations, embodying a collective hair care legacy .

For instance, historical accounts describe enslaved African Americans using eating forks, sometimes heated, as makeshift hot combs to straighten hair. While a stark reminder of forced assimilation, this also speaks to an ingenuity in adapting available tools to achieve desired styles, often in conjunction with lubricants like lard. In pre-colonial Africa, hair care rituals involved washing, combing, oiling, braiding, twisting, and decorating hair with cloth, beads, or shells. The combs used were likely crafted from wood or bone, designed to navigate the unique structure of coiled strands.

The deliberate and slow process of using these tools, combined with the application of oils, prevented damage and ensured the hair remained pliable and healthy. This mindful engagement with hair and tools speaks to a respect for the hair’s capabilities, understanding that gentle, consistent care, supported by natural emollients, was the path to its enduring health.

Relay

Having traversed the foundational anatomy and the applied artistry of textured hair care, we now stand at the threshold of a more expansive inquiry ❉ How does ancestral oiling inform a holistic approach to hair health and problem-solving, reaching beyond the superficial to touch the very core of our cultural and historical intelligence ? This query invites us to consider the less apparent complexities, the intricate dance where science, culture, and heritage converge. It is a summons to profound insight, a recognition that the wisdom of generations past is not merely anecdotal but a testament to sustained efficacy, often validated by contemporary understanding. This section will bypass surface-level discussions, providing a deep understanding of ancestral oiling, buttressed by research and scholarship, analyzing its multifaceted contributions to textured hair care from biological, social, and cultural viewpoints .

Building Personalized Regimens from Ancient Wisdom

The construction of an effective hair care regimen for textured hair today often involves a meticulous selection of products and practices tailored to individual needs. This modern personalization, however, finds a compelling precursor in ancestral wisdom, where care was inherently individualized, guided by intimate knowledge of one’s hair, environment, and available resources. Communities did not operate with a single, universal hair product; instead, they adapted. For instance, in West Africa, the utilization of oils from indigenous trees varied among ethnic groups, with preferences for specific species like shea (Vitellaria paradoxa) or palm oil (Elaeis guineensis) for hair care, often alongside other uses such as medicine or body care.

(Ouédraogo et al. 2013) This localized knowledge underscores a deeply personalized approach, where the efficacy of oiling was understood not in generic terms, but within the context of specific botanicals and their properties. The wisdom lay in observation, trial, and the communal transmission of what worked best for particular hair types and scalp conditions.

This historical personalization was also shaped by hair porosity, a concept that modern science now helps us articulate. Textured hair often exhibits higher porosity, meaning its cuticle layers are more open, allowing moisture to enter and exit rapidly. Oils, particularly those capable of penetrating the hair shaft like coconut or olive oil, can help seal these cuticles, reducing moisture loss. Ancestral practitioners, without the language of porosity, understood this need for sealing.

They observed that certain oils created a lasting sheen and maintained softness, intuitively recognizing their protective role. For those with low porosity hair, where cuticles are tightly packed, lighter oils or pre-poo treatments were often favored to prevent buildup and aid absorption. This practical application of knowledge, passed down through generations, demonstrates a sophisticated, albeit unscientific, understanding of hair’s response to different oil types, providing a template for building personalized regimens today.

The Nighttime Sanctuary and Bonnet Wisdom

The practice of protecting textured hair during sleep, now widely recognized for its role in preventing friction and moisture loss, holds a profound historical lineage . The silk bonnet or scarf, a staple in many textured hair care routines, carries the echoes of ancestral wisdom concerning nighttime rituals. In many African cultures, headwraps were not merely fashion statements; they often signified age, marital status, or prosperity.

Beyond their social markers, these coverings also served a practical purpose ❉ shielding elaborate hairstyles from dust, preserving moisture, and protecting the hair during rest. This nightly ritual transformed hair care from a daytime activity into a continuous, mindful practice, extending its protection through hours of sleep.

The historical context of head coverings, particularly for Black women, also bears the weight of forced adaptation during slavery, where scarves were used to conceal matted or unkempt hair due to lack of access to proper care. Yet, even in oppression, the act of covering one’s hair became a quiet act of dignity and self-preservation. This dual function—protection and cultural significance—is what lends such profound meaning to the modern bonnet.

It is not simply a piece of fabric; it is a symbol of resilience , a tangible link to a heritage that valued hair as a sacred extension of self. The oils applied before bed, often sealed in by these coverings, would work their restorative properties overnight, a silent testament to the efficacy of consistent, ancestral practices.

Ancestral oiling, when understood through the lens of hair porosity and integrated with the protective ritual of nighttime coverings, stands as a testament to the enduring efficacy of inherited wisdom in safeguarding textured hair.

Ingredient Deep Dives for Textured Hair Needs

The effectiveness of ancestral oiling rests upon the profound understanding of natural ingredients cultivated over millennia. Our ancestors possessed an intimate knowledge of their local flora, discerning which plant oils and butters offered the most potent benefits for hair health. This ethnobotanical wisdom forms the bedrock of modern natural hair care. Many of these traditional ingredients are now validated by scientific inquiry, revealing the underlying mechanisms of their protective qualities.

• Shea Butter (Vitellaria Paradoxa) ❉ Derived from the nuts of the shea tree, a staple in West African traditions, shea butter is renowned for its moisturizing and protective properties. It acts as a sealant, preventing moisture loss and increasing softness, and possesses anti-inflammatory qualities beneficial for the scalp.
• Coconut Oil (Cocos Nucifera) ❉ Widely used across various cultures, including African and Indian traditions, coconut oil is one of the few oils that can penetrate the hair shaft, providing deep conditioning and reducing protein loss. It is particularly beneficial for high porosity hair by helping to protect it from water damage and filling in damaged cuticles.
• Castor Oil (Ricinus Communis) ❉ Historically used in ancient Egypt for hair growth and texture improvement, castor oil is a thick, emollient oil that provides a protective coating and can help to seal in moisture.
• Baobab Oil (Adansonia Digitata) ❉ Sourced from the African baobab tree, this oil is rich in fatty acids, contributing to hair strength, repair, and shine, echoing its use in ancient Egyptian-inspired formulas.

The deliberate selection and application of these oils were not random acts; they were informed by generations of observation and collective experience. The knowledge of which oils to use for specific concerns—be it dryness, breakage, or scalp irritation—was passed down, often orally, within families and communities. This deep understanding of natural remedies speaks to a sophisticated system of traditional medicine that recognized the interconnectedness of external applications and overall well-being. The sustained popularity of these ancestral oils today, often as foundational components of modern textured hair products, is a testament to their timeless efficacy and their deep roots in hair heritage .

Holistic Influences on Hair Health

The ancestral approach to hair care was rarely compartmentalized; it was intrinsically linked to a broader philosophy of holistic well-being. The question of whether ancestral oiling protects textured hair today cannot be fully answered without considering this wider lens. For our ancestors, hair health was a reflection of internal balance, influenced by diet, spiritual practices, and communal harmony. The application of oils was often accompanied by scalp massage, a practice known to stimulate circulation and promote overall scalp health, thereby supporting hair growth.

The communal aspect of hair care rituals also contributed to holistic well-being. These were moments of social connection, storytelling, and the transmission of cultural knowledge . The act of a mother oiling her child’s hair, or women gathering to braid each other’s strands, fostered bonds and reinforced a sense of belonging.

This social dimension of hair care, where self-care became community care, undoubtedly contributed to a reduction in stress, a factor now recognized by modern science as impacting hair health. The legacy of ancestral oiling, therefore, is not solely about the physical benefits derived from the oils themselves, but also about the enduring impact of these practices on mental, emotional, and social well-being, affirming that true protection extends beyond the strand to the very soul of a people’s heritage .

Relay

As we consider the question of whether ancestral oiling truly protects textured hair today, we ascend to a higher vantage point, one that encompasses the profound interplay of biological realities, scientific validation, and the enduring power of cultural narratives . This inquiry moves beyond simple efficacy, probing the less apparent complexities that reveal the timeless wisdom embedded within our textured hair heritage . It is an invitation into a space of profound insight, where ancient practices and contemporary understanding converge, illuminating the multifaceted contributions of ancestral oiling to hair health and identity. We seek not just answers, but a deeper comprehension of how science and tradition intertwine to safeguard our strands, and in doing so, preserve a legacy.

The Biomechanics of Oil Absorption and Hair Porosity

The protective capacity of ancestral oiling is intimately tied to the biomechanics of how oils interact with the unique structure of textured hair. Unlike straight hair, the coiled and kinked patterns of textured hair mean that natural sebum, produced by the scalp, struggles to descend the full length of the hair shaft, leaving the ends particularly vulnerable to dryness. This inherent structural reality contributes to textured hair’s tendency towards higher porosity, a state where the hair’s outermost cuticle layer is more raised or compromised. When the cuticle is raised, the hair can absorb moisture quickly, but also loses it just as rapidly, leading to dryness and susceptibility to damage.

Ancestral oiling practices, often employing a range of plant-derived lipids, provided a critical external lipid barrier. Oils, being hydrophobic, repel water, and when applied to porous hair, they can coat the cuticle, forming a protective layer that slows down moisture evaporation. This sealing action is particularly beneficial for high porosity hair, helping it to retain the hydration it readily absorbs. However, the type of oil matters significantly.

Penetrating oils, such as coconut oil, can actually move beyond the cuticle and into the hair cortex, offering internal conditioning and reducing protein loss, thereby fortifying the strand from within. Conversely, sealing oils, like castor or grapeseed, primarily sit on the surface, providing external protection and shine. The intuitive wisdom of ancestral practitioners, who often layered different oils or used them in specific sequences, aligns remarkably with modern scientific understanding of porosity and lipid interactions. This sophisticated understanding, honed over generations, demonstrates a deep empirical knowledge of hair’s needs.

A study on traditional knowledge of native trees in Burkina Faso revealed that oils were used for hair care, among other applications, with significant differences in knowledge and preferences among ethnic groups. (Ouédraogo et al. 2013) This highlights how the choice of oil was not arbitrary but rooted in localized ethnobotanical understanding and tailored to specific environmental conditions and hair types. The continuous application of these traditional oils over time contributed to a cumulative protective effect, strengthening the hair’s lipid barrier and maintaining its elasticity, thereby mitigating the daily stresses that lead to breakage and damage.

Beyond the Surface ❉ Oil’s Impact on Hair Health Markers

The protective claims of ancestral oiling extend beyond mere cosmetic appeal; they influence measurable markers of hair health. While direct scientific studies specifically on “ancestral oiling” as a historical practice are limited, the properties of the oils traditionally used have been extensively researched. The benefits observed by our ancestors—reduced breakage, improved length retention, and enhanced vitality—are now increasingly understood through the lens of modern hair science.

For instance, the reduction of hygral fatigue, the repeated swelling and shrinking of the hair shaft due to water absorption and desorption, is a significant protective benefit of oiling. This constant fluctuation can weaken the hair cuticle over time, leading to damage. Coconut oil, in particular, has been shown to reduce water sorption and hygral fatigue, thus supporting hair moisture retention and fortification. This scientific validation provides a compelling explanation for the ancestral observation that consistent oiling contributed to stronger, more resilient hair.

The antioxidants and fatty acids present in many natural oils, such as jojoba, argan, and olive oils, also protect textured hair from environmental factors like UV rays and changing weather conditions. This external shield complements the internal conditioning, offering a comprehensive defense against daily stressors.

Furthermore, the physical act of oiling, often involving gentle massage, contributes to scalp health, which is foundational for robust hair growth. A healthy scalp environment, free from excessive dryness or irritation, supports the hair follicle in producing strong strands. The use of oils like neem, historically applied for dandruff and breakage, or onion oil for similar concerns, reflects an ancestral understanding of the scalp as an integral part of hair health. The continuity of these practices, from ancient rituals to modern routines, speaks to an enduring truth ❉ that consistent, mindful application of natural oils, rooted in deep heritage , offers tangible and scientifically explainable protection for textured hair today.

Cultural Resilience and the Future of Hair Heritage

The continued practice of ancestral oiling in contemporary society is not simply a matter of efficacy; it is a powerful statement of cultural resilience and identity. For centuries, textured hair has been a site of both celebration and struggle, facing discrimination and pressure to conform to Eurocentric beauty standards. From the forced shaving of heads during slavery to the social pressures that led many Black women to chemically alter their hair, the journey of textured hair has been intertwined with broader historical narratives of oppression and liberation.

The resurgence of interest in ancestral oiling and other traditional hair care practices, particularly within the modern natural hair movement, represents a conscious reclaiming of hair heritage . This movement, which gained momentum in the 2000s, encouraged people of African descent to embrace their natural textures, disrupting Eurocentric beauty ideals and fostering self-definition. By returning to the wisdom of their ancestors, individuals are not only seeking healthier hair but also affirming their cultural identity and connection to a rich past.

The act of oiling, once a communal ritual in pre-colonial Africa, becomes a personal and collective act of self-love and cultural affirmation in the present. It symbolizes a refusal to abandon practices that have sustained generations, even when faced with societal pressures.

The integration of ancestral oiling into modern hair care routines, often through Black-owned businesses that prioritize natural ingredients and Afrocentric values , also represents an economic and social empowerment. These businesses serve as pillars, providing resources and fostering a sense of community around shared hair heritage . The future of textured hair care, therefore, lies not in abandoning ancestral wisdom for purely scientific innovation, but in a harmonious dialogue between the two.

It is in understanding the scientific underpinnings of why these ancient practices work, while simultaneously honoring the profound cultural and historical significance they carry. This synthesis allows ancestral oiling to continue to offer genuine protection, not just for the hair itself, but for the enduring spirit of a people’s legacy .

Reflection

As we draw this exploration to a close, the question of whether ancestral oiling truly protects textured hair today resolves into a resonant affirmation. The answer is not a simple yes or no, but a symphony of interconnected truths, a testament to the enduring power of heritage . From the biological nuances of the coiled strand to the profound cultural narratives that have shaped its journey, ancestral oiling emerges as far more than a mere beauty practice. It is a living archive, a repository of wisdom passed through generations, its efficacy validated by both the whispers of history and the discerning gaze of modern science.

This journey has revealed that the protection offered by ancestral oiling is multifaceted. It shields the physical strand from dryness and damage, its lipids providing a barrier against environmental aggressors. It nourishes the scalp, the very soil from which our hair springs. Beyond the tangible, it safeguards something even more profound ❉ the identity and spirit of those whose hair tells stories of resilience, artistry, and unwavering self-acceptance.

In each drop of oil, in every gentle application, there is a connection to a past that refuses to be erased, a celebration of what was, what is, and what will continue to be. The ‘Soul of a Strand’ ethos finds its deepest expression here, in the recognition that our hair is a continuous thread, linking us to our ancestors, anchoring us in the present, and guiding us toward a future where our textured hair heritage shines unbound and unyielding.

References

• Ouédraogo, A. Lykke, A. M. Lankoandé, B. & Korbéogo, G. (2013). Potentials for Promoting Oil Products Identified from Traditional Knowledge of Native Trees in Burkina Faso. Ethnobotany Research and Applications, 11, 071–083.
• Patton, T. O. (2006). Hey Girl, Am I More Than My Hair? African American Women and Their Struggles with Beauty, Body Image, and Hair. Black Women, Gender & Family, 25(2), 22-35.
• Rele, V. J. & Mohile, R. B. (2003). Effect of mineral oil, sunflower oil, and coconut oil on prevention of hair damage. Journal of Cosmetic Science, 54(2), 175-192.
• Sherrow, V. (2006). Encyclopedia of Hair ❉ A Cultural History. Greenwood Publishing Group.
• Byrd, A. L. & Tharps, L. D. (2001). Hair Story ❉ Untangling the Roots of Black Hair in America. St. Martin’s Press.
• Akbari, R. et al. (2016). A Review on Herbal Medicines for Hair Care. Journal of Traditional and Complementary Medicine, 6(1), 1-11.
• Mohammad, M. (2019). Hair ❉ A Cultural History. Bloomsbury Academic.
• Jackson, D. D. (2006). Hair Matters ❉ Beauty, Power, and Black Women’s Consciousness. Routledge.